🔔 Stay Updated!

Get instant alerts on breaking news, top stories, and updates from News EiSamay.

American woman calls Mumbai metro cleaner than New York metro, sparks online debate

An American woman’s praise for Mumbai Metro as cleaner and more efficient than New York’s metro has gone viral, triggering discussions on India’s public transport standards.

By Neelormi Ray Chowdhury

Jun 20, 2026 02:50 IST

An American woman's first ride on the Mumbai Metro has captured online attention after she shared her reaction to the fast train. In the video, she makes a comparison between the two, and mentions cleanliness, safety aspects and affordability.

The post went up on Instagram from an account named spicygori run by Liz and Shiv.

Tidier than New York

The woman, Liz, who shared her experience on social media, appreciated the cleanliness, punctuality and experience of commuters while using the Mumbai Metro. She said the stations looked very clean and the trains were a lot cleaner than what she had seen while traveling in New York. Her words struck a chord with social media users, who were also in agreement that newer metros in India are setting high benchmarks for public transport, as stated by the Hindustan Times.

The post garnered significant attention and comments, with users sharing their experiences and insights about how the metros in Indian cities like Mumbai and New Delhi have come to represent modern urban living. Several commenters noted that the air-conditioned coaches, maintenance of the stations and digital ticketing systems help to make travel easier.

Also Read | From Kalamkari art to Thekua: What PM Modi gifted leaders in France and Slovakia

Praise and debate

Many users appreciated the comparison, though some pointed out that Mumbai Metro is much younger than the over 100-year-old New York subway system, which carries millions of riders every day. Those who along with others argued that it is not a fair comparison at all because of size, age, and ridership differences.

Regardless, congratulations on a job well done and the increased support for more modern transit systems with private investments for transit infrastructure improvements and upgrades in Mumbai. Public figures and first-time users have recently echoed similar opinions of a clean, efficient, and world-class transit system regarding their experience on the Mumbai Metro.

Growing reputation

As the metro line continues to grow in Mumbai, commuters, travelers and residents have responded in favor. Proponents of the new line believe that this system provides an alternative to commuting by automobile and that it enhances connectivity within the city. There is a hope amongst passengers that once all lines are constructed there will be a significant change in how millions travel on a day-to-day basis.

Also Read | Forget chasing love — this method says 'burn the haystack' instead

FAQs

Q1: What did the American woman say about Mumbai Metro?

Ans: She said Mumbai Metro was cleaner and more efficient than New York’s subway system.

Q2: Why did her comments go viral?

Ans: The comparison sparked discussions about the quality of public transport in India versus major global cities.

Articles you may like: